SILVERNAIL VILLAGE What you'd walk away with
Silvernail Village · November 2026

Source ledger

Every figure in the study traces to a recorded document, a signed lease, a management statement, or a closed deed. This page lists the full candidate pool behind each comp set, including every cut, plus the document library and the verification paths.

Back to the study

The subject file

Owner-side financial statements, executed leases, tax bills, and recorded condominium filings. Staged PDFs open in the document library below; working-paper files are named for the audit trail.

Anderson Commercial Group monthly report (Sep 30, 2026)Rent roll, income statement, balance sheet, general ledger, insurance, and WaterStone loan093026-Silvernail-Village-Monthly-Report.pdf
L & A Appraisal report (Oct 28, 2024)Year built, zoning, SF split, and 2024 appraisal value ($2,230,000 at 9.75% cap)2301-2345-Silvernail-OM-or-Doc.pdf
Signed purchase contract (Jul 31, 2024)$2,170,000 purchase price and $40,000 seller creditSilvernail-Purchase-Contract-Signed.pdf
Waukesha County 2024 and 2025 property tax bills21-unit assessments and 2024 vs. 2025 property tax billssubject-tax-waukesha.json
WisDOT annual average daily traffic countsDaily traffic counts on Silvernail Rd, Grandview Blvd, and I-94wisdot-traffic-waukesha-mke.json
Mid-America Real Estate OM, 2177 Silvernail RdSigned strip leases ($16.30/SF and $21.00/SF NN), 8.81x GRM, and 6.83% cap on the unsold neighboring stripdata/source-docs/garber-neighboring-sale/Silvernail Plaza OM NEW Compressed.pdf
Suntide Commercial Realty sale brochure, Pewaukee Crossings (Dec 2025)$2,750,000 ask and $234,279 NOI prior to the Jul 2026 $2,500,000 sale (9.37% cap)data/source-docs/pewaukee-crossings-2025/6939b8cb97588f16fad5c47b_brochure_pewaukee_crossings_sale.pdf

Front Dry Retail Rents · Grandview & Silvernail Corridor

12 candidates reviewed · 7 fit · 5 cut. Every candidate is listed, including the cuts, so the curation is auditable.

CandidateVerdictReason
Silvernail Commons · Pewaukee Vapor (Ste B) (2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha)FITSNext door (0.21 mi, built 2002): signed dry-retail endcap lease converting to $13.71/SF NNN-equivalent against the center's audited $9.12/SF OpEx.
Grandview Plaza · Inline Dry Retail (1850-1860 Meadow Ln, Waukesha)FITSJust off N Grandview Blvd (0.51 mi): pure dry-retail strip bay with almost identical NNN load ($6.23/SF vs your $6.17/SF).
Silvernail Plaza West · Ste 2016 (2020 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha)FITSSame street (0.49 mi east): 1,244 SF dry inline bay directly matching your 1,250 SF April 2026 front inline signings ($14.50/SF NNN).
Silvernail Plaza West · Ste 2024 (2024 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha)FITSSame street (0.49 mi east): larger dry-retail bay confirming $15.00/SF NNN holds flat across both 1,244 SF and 4,715 SF suites on Silvernail Rd.
Silvernail Commons · Quick Cleaners (Ste D) (2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha)FITSNext door (0.21 mi): 1,200 SF dry-service storefront showing $26.00/SF all-in ($16.88/SF NNN-equivalent) in a 2002-built center.
Silvernail Commons · Ali Ali Healing (Ste F) (2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha)FITSNext door (0.21 mi, newer 2002 build): small 900 SF wellness/acupuncture storefront proving strong all-in occupancy power right on Silvernail Rd.
Silvernail Commons · Cher Nails (Ste G) (2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha)FITSNext door (0.21 mi, newer 2002 highway-pad strip): upper-bound nail salon comp alongside your April 2026 Believe Spa & Nails signing ($14.50/SF NNN + $6.17/SF = $20.67/SF all-in).
Silvernail Commons · Mom's Kitchen, 2177 Silvernail RdCUTSeparated into F&B / Hooded Restaurant callout so hooded restaurant rents do not skew dry-retail inline benchmarks.
Silvernail Commons · Papa Murphy's, 2177 Silvernail RdCUTSeparated into Food / F&B callout (Dec 2025 5-yr cold-prep renewal at $16.30/SF NN) to keep primary table 100% non-food dry retail.
Pewaukee Crossings, N20W22951 Watertown Rd (3.18 mi)CUTDropped from retail rent table: 7 immediate-corridor comps within 0.21-0.51 mi on Silvernail/Grandview make a 3.18-mi Hwy F center unnecessary.
President's Plaza, 101-177 W Sunset Dr (4.38 mi)CUTDropped from retail rent table: 4.38 mi south on Sunset Dr; immediate Silvernail/Grandview corridor supplies full dry-retail coverage.
Crestwood Plaza, 1921 Silvernail Rd (Dec 2020 SVN flyer)CUTArchived SVN flyer carries Dec 2020 PDF creation date (pre-2025 sale); excluded in favor of 2025-2026 corridor OMs and live flyers.

Back Suites (No Street Frontage) · True Office-Building Rents

13 candidates reviewed · 7 fit · 6 cut. Every candidate is listed, including the cuts, so the curation is auditable.

CandidateVerdictReason
Crestview Office Building · Ste G (N16W23390 Stone Ridge Dr, Pewaukee)FITSTrue corporate-park office/service suite without retail frontage ($8.50/SF NNN), directly anchoring our $9.00/SF + NNN rollover target on Mission Breakout (3,058 SF).
Stoneridge II Office Building · Ste 185 (N14W23777 Stone Ridge Dr, Pewaukee)FITS2.23 mi east in Pewaukee: true multi-story office building with zero retail street visibility that had to cut from $10.00/SF down to $9.00/SF NNN, matching Caught Looking ($9.33/SF NNN) and Mission Breakout ($9.00/SF NNN).
Crossroads Corporate Center I · Office Suites (20900 Swenson Dr, Waukesha)FITSPure Waukesha/Brookfield I-94 office park with separate suite entrances and zero retail frontage ($11.00/SF NNN + $4.50/SF NNN load = $15.50/SF all-in), replacing 137 Wisconsin Ave whose broker omitted NNN across all feeds.
West Wind Office Center · 41 Signed Office Suites (N27 W23953-W23960 Paul Rd, Pewaukee)FITS41 actual signed small-suite office tenants in a pure Pewaukee office park (zero retail visibility) clearing at $10.52/SF NNN-equivalent, setting the exact median for non-frontage office space.
1507 E Sunset Dr · Single-Story Office Building (1507 E Sunset Dr, Waukesha)FITSStandalone Waukesha office building (not a retail strip center) asking $11.00/SF NNN + $4.50/SF OpEx ($15.50/SF all-in), bracketing American Advantage Insurance ($11.33/SF NNN).
Silvernail Woods IV Office Park · Signed & Ste 111 (2607 N Grandview Blvd, Waukesha)FITS0.60 mi south on N Grandview Blvd: true 2-story interior-corridor office building (zero retail storefronts) proving $12.00/SF NNN on signed and active corridor office suites.
Ridgeview Office Center I · Interior Suites (N16W23217 Stone Ridge Dr, Pewaukee)FITSUpper end of pure interior-corridor suburban office in Pewaukee ($12.75/SF NNN + $8.98/SF Tax & CAM = $21.73/SF all-in across 4 small suites in a 3-story office building with zero retail visibility premium).
137 Wisconsin Ave, Waukesha · Lower Level (NAI Pfefferle)CUTExcluded because NAI Pfefferle omits the NNN/OpEx load across its flyer PDF, CARW/Moody's Exchange, and Crexi; replaced with Crossroads Corporate Center I ($11.00/SF NNN + $4.50/SF verified NNN load).
115 Main St, Pewaukee · MGM Laundries (PWV 0899958)CUTHistorical NNN details recovered from 07/21/2025 Newmark/Catylist report ($3.00/SF published NNN load, $1.24/SF actual 2025 county tax; $13.76/SF NNN signed renewal in CompStak #2823566). Excluded from Set 2 because 115 Main St is a street-fronting retail strip (MGM Laundries / Drita's Deli), whereas Silvernail's back suites have no street frontage.
Sussex Gateway Retail Center · Edward Jones (W249N5245 Executive Dr)CUTRetail strip-mall storefront paying a street-visibility premium; excluded from Set 2 so back-suite comps reflect true non-frontage office buildings.
Sussex Plaza · State Farm (N64W22622 Main St)CUTRetail strip-mall bay excluded from Set 2 in favor of pure office buildings with no retail street frontage.
Stone Ridge I, N14W23755 Stone Ridge Dr, Pewaukee (891d ask)CUT891-day stale listing replaced by fresh Stone Ridge II ($9.00/SF NNN) and West Wind Office Center OM ($10.52/SF NNN-eq across 41 signed suites).
1930 W Bluemound Rd, Waukesha (529d ask)CUT529-day stale asking flyer replaced by verified office OMs and fresh office-building flyers.

Recent sales

16 candidates reviewed · 7 fit · 9 cut. Every candidate is listed, including the cuts, so the curation is auditable.

CandidateVerdictReason
2100 Silvernail Rd (2100-2160), PewaukeeFITSAcross the street on Silvernail Rd (0.25 mi): 06-07-2024 deed ($12,330,000, $106.17/SF) for Silvernail Plaza (116,135 SF Metro Market and Dollar Tree center; 95.0% occupied per Oct 2026 SEC ABS-EE).
2000 Silvernail Rd, WaukeshaFITSSame street (0.39 mi): 07-13-2026 deed ($4,450,000, $97.86/SF) for Silvernail Plaza West (45,473 SF GIS / 45,597 SF OM multi-tenant strip, listed Sep 2025 at $4,600,000 at 73.5% occupancy with 12,106 SF available on OM cover & p. 5 and $4.00/SF actual NNN).
1921 Silvernail Rd, Pewaukee (City of Waukesha)FITSSame block (0.40 mi): 03-21-2025 deed ($1,150,000, $167.71/SF) for Crestwood Commons Plaza (6,857 SF, 4-suite strip).
707 W Moreland Blvd, WaukeshaCUTCut: 2-story Class C elevator office building (18,808 SF GBA / 14,080 SF RBA, WI DOR RETR sub_type='Office'); not a retail strip center.
1275 Capitol Dr, PewaukeeFITSPewaukee Commons, 1275 Capitol Dr (3.17 mi): 11-20-2025 deed ($3,750,000, $112.48/SF, 7.34% cap on $275,286 NOI) for a 33,338 SF Pewaukee retail strip parcel.
N20W22951 Watertown Rd, PewaukeeFITSClosed 07/31/2026 Pewaukee condo strip (3.18 mi): $234,279 brochure NOI over $2,500,000 deed = 9.37% cap (includes 2-yr seller master lease on vacant 2,113 SF Ste 105; 93.2% headline occ vs. 79.8% organic).
W249N5245 Executive Dr, SussexFITS4.77 mi away in Sussex: 07/31/2026 deed ($3,550,000, $142.95/SF, 7.50% cap) for a 24,834 SF, 9-suite strip.
2212 E Moreland Blvd, WaukeshaCUTAlternate: $1,200,000 ($98.04/SF, 12,240 SF office/retail, 3.94 mi).
144 E Summit Ave, WalesCUTAlternate: $1,125,000 ($89.82/SF, 12,525 SF office/medical/retail, 6.17 mi).
13845 W North Ave, BrookfieldCUTAlternate: Brookfield submarket (9.06 mi).
18550 W Capitol Dr, BrookfieldCUTAlternate: Brookfield submarket (6.99 mi).
15420 W Capitol Dr, BrookfieldCUTAlternate: Brookfield submarket (8.68 mi).
W359N5002 Brown St, OconomowocCUTAlternate: Oconomowoc grocery-anchored center (11.19 mi).
13300 Watertown Plank Rd, Elm GroveCUTClosed 07/31/2026 Pewaukee condo strip (3.18 mi): $234,279 brochure NOI over $2,500,000 deed = 9.37% cap (includes 2-yr seller master lease on vacant 2,113 SF Ste 105; 93.2% headline occ vs. 79.8% organic).
1306-1330 S 108th St, West AllisCUT$49.76/SF at 67% occupancy in West Allis (10.95 mi).
Falls Crossing, N84 W15700 Appleton Ave, Menomonee FallsFITSClosed 03/20/2026 ($5,875,000, WI RETR Doc #4866221, 9.04% cap on Founders 3 OM NOI): 48,567 SF 4-tenant NNN retail center ($120.97/SF; $1,468,750/suite across 4 junior-anchor boxes).

Gross rent multiples

13 candidates reviewed · 6 fit · 7 cut. Every candidate is listed, including the cuts, so the curation is auditable.

CandidateVerdictReason
Silvernail Commons, 2177 Silvernail Rd, PewaukeeFITS7-unit single-owner strip 0.21 mi east: $2,090,000 ask over $237,150 in-place revenue (8.81x GRM); pulled unsold Apr 2026.
Silvernail Plaza, 2160 Silvernail Rd, PewaukeeFITSClosed 06/07/2024 deed ($12,330,000) divided by SEC-audited T-12 revenue ($1,646,564 = 7.49x GRM) across the street.
Pewaukee Crossings Condo, N20W22951 Watertown Rd, PewaukeeFITS9-suite Pewaukee condo strip closed 07/31/2026 at $2,500,000 over $224,251 OM gross revenue (11.15x GRM).
Heartland Dental and AT&T Shops, 701 E Sunset Dr, WaukeshaFITSClosed 09/05/2025 Waukesha NNN strip ($3,600,000 deed) over $377,796 OM gross income (9.53x GRM).
Sussex Plaza, N64W22622 Main St, SussexFITSActive 9-suite Sussex NNN strip ($2,550,000 ask) over $329,968 2026 OM gross revenue (7.73x GRM).
Moorland Square, 3830 S Moorland Rd, New BerlinFITS4-suite New Berlin NNN strip ($2,300,000 ask) over $262,621 OM gross income (8.76x GRM).
1900 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha (Arby's)CUTAlternate: 1900 Silvernail Rd Arby's (16.67x); single-tenant fast-food pad.
19395 W Capitol Dr, BrookfieldCUTBrookfield office condo building (9.74x ask).
5250 S 108th St, Hales CornersCUTMilwaukee County medical/dental office (10.32x).
Silvernail Plaza, 2160 Silvernail Rd, PewaukeeCUTCMBS lender revenue basis for 2160 Silvernail Rd (shown in row drawer).
19395 W Capitol Dr, BrookfieldCUTBase-rent-only basis for 19395 W Capitol Dr.
5250 S 108th St, Hales CornersCUTBase-rent-only basis for 5250 S 108th St.
Brookfield Plaza, 13800 W Greenfield Ave, BrookfieldCUTAlternate: 6-suite strip asking $1,600,000 on $173,682 income (9.21x); Brookfield submarket.

Cap rates

20 candidates reviewed · 7 fit · 13 cut. Every candidate is listed, including the cuts, so the curation is auditable.

CandidateVerdictReason
Silvernail Commons, 2177 Silvernail Rd, PewaukeeFITS7-unit single-owner strip next door (0.21 mi): asked $2,090,000 on $142,782 in-place NOI (6.83% cap) and pulled unsold Apr 2026.
Silvernail Plaza, 2160 Silvernail Rd, PewaukeeFITSClosed 06/07/2024 across the street: SEC-audited T-12 NOI $1,100,118 over $12,330,000 deed = 8.92% cap.
Pewaukee Commons, 1275 Capitol Dr, PewaukeeFITSClosed 11/20/2025 Pewaukee retail sale (3.17 mi): $275,286 NOI over $3,750,000 deed = 7.34% cap.
Pewaukee Crossings Condo, N20W22951 Watertown Rd, PewaukeeFITSClosed 07/31/2026 Pewaukee condo strip (3.18 mi): $234,279 brochure NOI over $2,500,000 deed = 9.37% cap (includes 2-yr seller master lease on vacant 2,113 SF Ste 105; 93.2% headline occ vs. 79.8% organic).
Heartland Dental and AT&T Shops, 701 E Sunset Dr, WaukeshaFITSClosed 09/05/2025 Waukesha NNN strip (4.57 mi): $276,957 OM NOI over $3,600,000 deed = 7.69% cap.
Sussex Plaza, N64W22622-N64W22694 Main St, SussexFITSActive 9-suite Sussex NNN strip (7.06 mi): asking $2,550,000 on $210,568 2026 NOI = 8.25% cap.
Falls Crossing, N84 W15700 Appleton Ave, Menomonee FallsFITSClosed 03/20/2026 Waukesha County strip (10.82 mi): $531,049 OM NOI over $5,875,000 deed = 9.04% cap.
N19W24101 Riverwood Dr, PewaukeeCUTCorporate office building (9.18% asking cap).
501 S Grand Ave, WaukeshaCUTDowntown Waukesha mixed storefront ask (7.40%).
Brookfield Plaza, 13800-13870 W Greenfield Ave, BrookfieldCUTAlternate: $1,600,000 ask on $124,222 NOI (7.76% cap); Brookfield submarket.
Plaza 108, 1461-1511 S 108th St, West AllisCUTAlternate: West Allis, Milwaukee County (7.76% ask).
19555 W Bluemound Rd, BrookfieldCUT$16,950,000 Brookfield ask (6.90% cap, NOI unpublished).
N79 W14700 Appleton Ave, Menomonee FallsCUT5.05% single-tenant pad ask.
12555 W National Ave, New BerlinCUTSingle-tenant outpatient medical facility.
5250 S 108th St, Hales CornersCUTMedical/dental office in Milwaukee County.
18200 W Capitol Dr, Brookfield (SAAK Health MOB)CUTMedical office building (NOI unpublished).
12645 W Burleigh Rd, BrookfieldCUTBrookfield office with conflicting cap and NOI figures.
Sussex Gateway Retail Center, W249N5245 Executive Dr, SussexCUTAlternate: closed 07/31/2026 at $3,550,000 ($142.95/SF, doc 4889828) at 7.50% published cap; dollar NOI not printed separately (included in Recent sales).
Delafield Square Retail Condo, 601 Genesee St, DelafieldCUTAsked $3,570,000 ($259.13/SF, 6.51% cap on $232,299 NOI) and pulled unsold Oct 29, 2026.
Moorland Square, 3830 S Moorland Rd, New BerlinCUTAlternate: cut from $2,527,000 to $2,300,000 ($178.43/SF, 8.15% cap on $187,439 NOI); still unsold.

Held alternates

Sussex Plaza, N64W22622 Main St, Sussex (8.25%)CUTAlternate: active $2,550,000 asking listing at 8.25% cap ($210,331 OM NOI, 100% occupied, 2.07 yr WALT; included in GRM table, held behind 6 closed Waukesha County cap-rate deeds).

NNN occupancy-cost benchmarks

Your billed 2026 NNN load$6.17/SFFour 2026 executed leases bill NNN at $6.17/SF: 642.71x12/1,250 (Piano Lab, Believe Spa), 851.97x12/1,657 (Essentially For You), 746.64x12/1,451 (Caught Looking); 09/30/2026 Anderson rent roll.
Your actual cost after the tax appeal$5.53/SF(association dues $116,754.39 + 2025 billed tax $28,370.08 + insurance $6,596.00) / 27,458 SF = $5.53/SF before management fee. Pre-appeal: $6.10/SF; the appeal removed $0.57/SF.
Waukesha County, Oct 2025 sweep$5.47/SF median98 centers, 143 listings; mean $5.98, interquartile $4.02 to $7.22.
CARW, Nov 2026 sweep$5.49/SF median73 centers; non-Brookfield strip-only median $5.79 across 28 centers.
Corridor tax rank1 of 17Your 2025 net tax $1.03/SF is the lowest of the 17 strip centers within 1.25 miles (median $2.06/SF; 2177 Silvernail carries $2.60/SF).

Across 98 Waukesha County multi-tenant retail centers (143 listings), NNN pass-through loads average $5.98/SF with a $5.47/SF median ($5.79/SF across non-Brookfield strip centers). Your $6.17/SF billed load sits right in the middle of neighboring Silvernail and Grandview strips ($4.18 to $7.70/SF), and your $1.03/SF post-appeal property tax is the lowest of all 17 strip centers within 1.25 miles (median $2.06/SF; 2177 Silvernail next door pays $2.60/SF).

Primary source documents (45 PDFs)

Staged locally and served with the study. Every OM, flyer, SEC annex, DOM proof, declaration, and rendering cited anywhere on the site lives here.

Tax & deed verification paths

Waukesha County property tax

tax.waukeshacounty.gov ↗ · Open https://tax.waukeshacounty.gov -> Search Parcel ID -> enter the Tax Key (for example WAKC0974017) -> Tax Listing / Tax Bill -> select the Tax Year

Portal deep-link URLs that carry a parcel key in the query string redirect to the portal home without a session cookie minted by the on-site search, so they are never published. The portal root, the exact Tax Key and the click path are published instead, and every unit record repeats them.

  • 2301WAKC0974017
  • 2303WAKC0974018
  • 2305WAKC0974019
  • 2307WAKC0974020
  • 2309WAKC0974021
  • 2315WAKC0974024
  • 2317WAKC0974025
  • 2319WAKC0974026
  • 2321WAKC0974027
  • 2323WAKC0974028
  • 2325WAKC0974029
  • 2327WAKC0974030
  • 2329WAKC0974031
  • 2331WAKC0974032
  • 2333WAKC0974033
  • 2335WAKC0974034
  • 2337WAKC0974035
  • 2343WAKC0974038
  • 2345WAKC0974039
  • 2339AWAKC0974036
  • 2339BWAKC0974036001

Recorded deeds

In-place leases at 2177 Silvernail Rd come directly from the Mid-America Offering Memorandum rent roll (p. 12); active lease asks come from verified local broker flyers and Crexi; closed sales, GRMs, and realized cap rates come from 69 gap-free months of WI DOR RETR deeds paired with SEC filings and broker OMs. Sale prices, dates, grantors, grantees, and document numbers in the sales table come from the WI DOR Real Estate Transfer return file; each row carries its recorded document number for Register of Deeds lookup.

Traffic counts

LocationAADTYearSource
I-94 between CTH G and CTH T72,8002022TRADS 672816 · 966 m from the center. WisDOT TRAFFIC_COUNTS ArcGIS layer (dotmaps.wi.gov), fields TRADS_ID / RDWY_AADT / AADT_RPTG_YR / TRFC_PT_LOC_DESC
N Grandview Blvd / CTH T, the signalized corner east of the center22,4002022TRADS 670473 · 623 m from the center. WisDOT TRAFFIC_COUNTS ArcGIS layer (dotmaps.wi.gov), fields TRADS_ID / RDWY_AADT / AADT_RPTG_YR / TRFC_PT_LOC_DESC
Silvernail Road at the center's frontage8,1002022TRADS 672121 · 409 m from the center. WisDOT TRAFFIC_COUNTS ArcGIS layer (dotmaps.wi.gov), fields TRADS_ID / RDWY_AADT / AADT_RPTG_YR / TRFC_PT_LOC_DESC

Curation rules

Gate: P5 Mission-Owner local strip-mall curation and W7 deep-research integration. Believability bar: Would Jay Orcholski (a Waukesha CRE owner who knows Silvernail Rd, Grandview Blvd, Meadow Ln, Moreland Blvd, Watertown Rd, and Lake Country) read this row and believe he can fetch that rent or that investors pay that rate here?

  • Zero Brookfield rows across all 5 primary comp tables (including cutting hidden Town of Brookfield BKFT parcels 180 Kossow Rd and 20825 Swenson Dr).
  • Comps only in every mean, median, and quartile; subject rows excluded.
  • In-place signed strip leases (Papa Murphy's $16.30/SF NN, Mom's Kitchen $21.00/SF NN at 2177 Silvernail Rd) lead #front-rents alongside 5 live Pewaukee/Waukesha strip asks.
  • Sales: 7 closed 2024-2026 retail-center WI DOR RETR deeds within 4.77 miles.
  • GRM: 6 pure non-Brookfield Waukesha County multi-tenant retail strip centers with documented OM/SEC gross revenue (median 8.79x).
  • Cap: 7 multi-tenant retail strip centers led by 5 closed deeds (7.34%, 7.69%, 8.92%, 9.04%, 9.37%; 6-trade closed median 8.31% incl. Sussex Gateway 7.50%), 1 active strip OM (Sussex Plaza 8.25%), and 1 withdrawn next-door ceiling (2177 Silvernail Commons 6.83%).