SILVERNAIL VILLAGE What you'd walk away with
Owner valuation · November 2026

Silvernail
VillageShopping Center · Waukesha, Wisconsin

2301-2345 Silvernail Rd, Pewaukee, WI 53072. City of Waukesha assesses it; Pewaukee is the mailing address. Same 21 units.

27,458 SF · 15 suites · 21 condo units · Built 1991 (phased 1989-1993) · B-5 Community Business District

Silvernail Village front plaza: pylon sign, stone-pillar pergola, and front retail suites Silvernail Rd frontage · Sept 2026
What you paid · Nov 2024
$2,170,000
9.45%

$79.03/SF · 89.6% occupied · 40% NNN · 1.66 yr

Bottom price
$3,649,999
9.00% cap

$328,397 on today's leases. Your 9.45% buy cap tightened 45 for the doubled WALT.

Aspirational
$3,999,999
8.25% cap

8.21% today / 8.26% at market. Assumes buyers accept tenant sales reports, vacancy fears are solved, and no condo discount.

Circulated off-market
$328,397NOI today 95.3%Occupied 2.91 yrWALT 83.8%NNN 67.3%Condo votes +$1.48M to +$1.83MEquity vs. purchase
The asset

A 1991 courtyard center on the Silvernail Road corridor.

21 commercial condo units inside a 31-unit association. Street-facing retail in front, two-level office and service suites in the back, 446 feet of frontage.

Total SF27,45816,040 front / 11,418 rear
Suites / units15 / 2114 occupied, 1 available
Frontage446 fton Silvernail Rd
Year built1991phased 1989-1993, condo from day one
Loan snapshot

WaterStone Bank

$1,582,542.70 balance (09/30/2026)
6.875% fixed · matures 12/01/2027
$13,840.21/mo total payment

Loan #32008685-7747. $166,082.52/yr debt service sits below NOI, never in the cap-rate math.

Insurance

Selective Insurance

$6,596/yr · policy S 2731371
10 installments of $660.00
Term 2025-12-02 to 2026-12-02 · $1,000 deductible

The association carries the master shell policy; this is the unit-owner policy.

Traffic ·

Corridor counts

72,800 vehicles/day · I-94 between CTH G and CTH T 2022 WisDOT count · 966 m away
22,400 vehicles/day · N Grandview Blvd / CTH T, the signalized corner east of the center 2022 WisDOT count · 623 m away
8,100 vehicles/day · Silvernail Road at the center's frontage 2022 WisDOT count · 409 m away

WisDOT TRAFFIC_COUNTS, 2022 reporting year.

The turnaround · Nov 2024 to Oct 2026
  • 2024-11-18
    Purchased 21 condo units (27,458 SF) for $2,170,000 ($79.03/SF) at 89.6% occupancy and 40.0% NNN coverage ($40,000 seller credit at closing).
  • 2025
    Won 2025 property tax appeal: assessment cut 26.0% ($2,930,500 to $2,170,000), dropping annual property taxes 36.3% ($44,446 to $28,370, saving $16,076/yr).
  • 2025-04-01
    Consolidated and converted American Advantage Insurance (Suites 2309, 2317 & 2321 · 3,242 SF) from Modified Gross to NNN through March 2032 ($11.33/SF + NNN).
  • 2025-07-01
    Renewed front-suite tenant Slowinski & Associates CPA (Suite 2333 · 971 SF) as-is with $0 TI for 3 years on NNN terms ($16.24 stepping to $17.23/SF NNN).
  • 2025-10-17
    Signed 5-year NNN renewal amendment with Midwest Dental (Suites 2303 & 2305 · 2,446 SF, term 02/01/2026 to 01/31/2031) at $18.90/SF NNN ($46,229/yr) with 3.25% annual bumps up to $21.48/SF, funding tenant improvements to lock in the dental anchor.
  • 2026-03-01
    Leased rear Suite 2329 (1,451 SF) in 19 days on market to Caught Looking Cards Inc. on a 3-year NNN lease ($9.33/SF amended base rent + $6.17/SF NNN, 4% annual bumps).
  • 2026-05-01
    Leased rear Suite 2345 (1,657 SF) to Essentially For You LLC on a 5-year NNN lease at $10.00/SF + $6.17/SF NNN with 4% annual bumps.
  • 2026-06-01
    Leased front Suite 2323 (1,250 SF) in 112 days on market to Believe Spa and Nails LLC on a 5-year NNN lease at $14.50/SF + $6.17/SF NNN (with Section 36 sales reporting).
  • 2026-07-01
    Leased front Suite 2315 (1,250 SF) to The Piano Lab LLC on a 5-year NNN lease at $14.50/SF + $6.17/SF NNN (with Section 36 sales reporting).
  • 2026-10-01
    Converted endcap restaurant Plaza Garibaldi (Suites 2301 & 2307 · 3,163 SF) from $12.71/SF Modified Gross to $20.00/SF NNN (+$42,583/yr combined base + NNN lift, with Section 36 sales reporting), taking NNN coverage to 83.8%.
Acquisition anchor

$2,170,000 · 11/18/2024

$79.03/SF across 27,458 SF, $144,667 per suite. Bought at 89.6% occupancy, 40% NNN, 1.66 yr WALT with 29.3% month-to-month, on a 9.45% cap against the 2024 OM's $205,004 NOI. $40,000 seller credit at closing.

Deed doc #4794033, Waukesha County. The Oct 2024 MAI appraisal concluded $2,230,000 as-is at 9.75%. 2024 acquisition OM PDF ↗

The rent roll

15 suites, 95.3% occupied, and the income is contracted.

One vacancy: Suite 2329A, 1,299 SF in the back courtyard. Everything else is leased, and 83.8% of the square footage now pays NNN.

Suite / tenantSFBase/mo/moStructureLease endDays on market
2301 & 2307Plaza Garibaldi (El Nayarita MTZ Restaurant LLC)3,163$5,271.6720.00$1,626.31NNN2027-04-305-yr extension option, 4% bumpsdirect ↗10/2026 NNN renewal (prior 1,153d)
2305 & 2303Midwest Dental2,446$3,852.4518.90$1,659.00NNN2031-01-31directRenewal / direct
2309, 2317 & 2321American Advantage Insurance3,242$3,060.9911.33$1,648.66NNN2032-03-31directRenewal / direct
2315The Piano Lab LLC1,250$1,510.4214.50$642.71NNN2031-08-31directRenewal / direct
2319Marillian Massage, LLC672$905.0716.16$551.52NNN2027-03-31319d ↗03/22/2021 -> 02/04/2022
2323Believe Spa and Nails, LLC1,250$1,510.4214.50$642.71NNN2031-05-31112d ↗01/06 -> 04/28/2026
2327 & 2325Black Gold Sports Cards, LLC2,974$3,746.7015.12$1,513.19NNN2029-07-312,276d ↗01/24/2018 -> 04/18/2024
2329Caught Looking Cards Inc.1,451$1,128.169.33$746.64NNN2029-02-2819d ↗02/04 -> 02/23/2026
2329AVacant1,299$0.000.00$0.00Availablen/an/a
2329BJavaTwist (storage)100$100.0012.00$0.00Gross (storage)n/adirectRenewal / direct
2331JavaTwist, LLC790$1,047.4115.91$581.61NNN2028-10-31253d ↗10/19/2022 -> 06/29/2023
2333Slowinski & Associates, SC971$1,353.4216.73$420.28NNN2028-06-30Pre-20182016 orig. · renewed in place
2335 & 2337Mission Breakout, LLC3,058$3,567.6714.00$0.00MG2027-12-31Pre-20182016 orig. · renewed in place
2343, 2339A & 2339BShepherd Chiropractic Clinic S.C.3,135$3,637.5713.92$1,535.95NNN2029-11-30Pre-20182015 orig. · renewed in place
2345Essentially For You LLC1,657$1,380.8310.00$851.97NNN2031-04-30209d ↗09/02/2025 -> 03/30/2026
Total · 10/01/202627,458$32,072.7814.49$12,420.5595.3% occ

Source: Anderson Commercial Group monthly report, 09/30/2026 (rent roll pp. 7-8), plus executed leases effective 10/01/2026. figures are contracted, not projected.

How the roll ties to the books (5 reconciliation notes)
  • The roll carries the 100 SF JavaTwist storage bay 2329B at $0.00 base rent, but the manager books $900 of storage rent to GL 4107-00 over the nine months to 09/30/2026, which is $100 a month. The roll total of $30,050.51 therefore excludes a $100 monthly storage charge that the operating statement collects. The income and expense map carries the $900 a year on its own Rent - Storage row so the two files tie without restating the roll.
  • Suite SF sums to 27,458, matching the roll's own total row.
  • The appraisal rent roll lists a 650 SF lower-back insurance unit as 2313 (Zach Lindow Agency). Anderson's current roll groups the same 650 SF inside suites 2309, 2317 and 2321 at 3,242 SF; 450 + 2,142 + 650 = 3,242. The 2313 label is not a separate tax key on the 21-unit county roll, so the study uses Anderson's suite numbers.
  • The appraisal lists suite 2329 at 2,850 SF. The current roll splits that space into 2329 (1,451 SF), 2329A (1,299 SF vacant) and 2329B (100 SF storage), which sums to 2,850 SF.
  • Surrounding condo units 2347, 2351 and 2353-2359 are owned by other parties and are excluded from every total here.
NNN coverage

From 40% to 83.8% in 24 months

83.8%
16.2%

At purchase (Oct 2024 appraisal): 40.0% NNN. Today: 11 of 15 suites pay ; Mission Breakout is the last lease ($14.00/SF all-in through 12/31/2027). Standard NNN load: $6.17/SF.

2027 rollover upside

Three leases come due in 2027

Marillian Massage (03/31), Plaza Garibaldi (04/30, with a 5-year extension option at 4% bumps), and Mission Breakout (12/31). Re-leasing the two back suites at market adds +$1,883/yr NOI and shifts $18,868/yr of expense risk to tenants.

At-market value on that plan: $3,669,779. Most leases are locked through 2029-2031, so the upside is focused, not speculative.

The market

Five comp sets. Every row sourced, every figure linked.

Signed corridor rents, closed deeds, gross rent multiples, and cap rates. Your building sits pinned at the top of each table so the comparison is direct, not abstract.

Seven signed dry-retail leases on the Grandview and Silvernail corridor, normalized to NNN-equivalent base rent. Your 8 front suites plus the Plaza Garibaldi endcap sit on top. Load is the uniform $6.17/SF quoted across your center.

Comps: 7 signed corridor leasesMedian $15.00/SFYour new inline leases $14.50/SFMarket inline $16.00/SF · restaurant $20.00/SF
$13$17$21$24$28Your new leasesRestaurantSilvernail Commons · Pewaukee Vapor (Ste B): $14 $/SF NNNGrandview Plaza · Inline Dry Retail: $14 $/SF NNNSilvernail Plaza West · Ste 2016: $15 $/SF NNNSilvernail Plaza West · Ste 2024: $15 $/SF NNNSilvernail Commons · Quick Cleaners (Ste D): $17 $/SF NNNSilvernail Commons · Ali Ali Healing (Ste F): $22 $/SF NNNSilvernail Commons · Cher Nails (Ste G): $27 $/SF NNN
Each dot is a comp. Click a dot to open its row. Yellow markers: your building. Axis: $/SF NNN.
Shepherd Chiropractic Clinic S.C.Suite 2343, 2339A & 2339B · NNN3,13513.926.1720.09NNNPre-20182015 orig. · renewed in place
The Piano Lab LLCSuite 2315 · NNN1,25014.506.1720.67NNNdirectRenewal / direct
Believe Spa and Nails, LLCSuite 2323 · NNN1,25014.506.1720.67NNN112d ↗01/06 -> 04/28/2026
Black Gold Sports Cards, LLCSuite 2327 & 2325 · NNN2,97415.126.1721.29NNN2,276d ↗01/24/2018 -> 04/18/2024
JavaTwist, LLCSuite 2331 · NNN79015.916.1722.08NNN253d ↗10/19/2022 -> 06/29/2023
Marillian Massage, LLCSuite 2319 · NNN (expiring 03/31/2027)67216.166.1722.33NNN (expiring 03/31/2027)319d ↗03/22/2021 -> 02/04/2022
Slowinski & Associates, SCSuite 2333 · NNN97116.736.1722.90NNNPre-20182016 orig. · renewed in place
Midwest DentalSuite 2305 & 2303 · NNN2,44618.906.1725.07NNNdirectRenewal / direct
Your Building · Plaza Garibaldi (Ste 2301 & 2307)Full commercial kitchen & exhaust hood · Signed NNN eff. 10/01/20263,16320.006.1726.17Signed NNN04/30/20275-yr extension optiondirectRenewal / direct
Silvernail Commons · Pewaukee Vapor (Ste B)2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha · 0.20 mi1,7501,500-2,000 SF dry retail endcap13.719.1222.83NNN-eq (Signed MG)2031-07-31113d ↗01/18 -> 05/11/2021 (Catylist #25515621)
Grandview Plaza · Inline Dry Retail1850-1860 Meadow Ln, Waukesha · 0.48 mi1,5001,500-6,346 SF divisible dry retail14.006.2320.23NNNn/a97dsince 08/13/2026
Silvernail Plaza West · Ste 20162020 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha · 0.39 mi1,6801,500-2,000 SF inline dry retail15.005.0020.00NNNn/a399dsince 10/15/2025
Silvernail Plaza West · Ste 20242024 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha · 0.39 mi4,7153,000-5,000 SF dry retail15.005.0020.00NNNn/a380dsince 11/03/2025
Silvernail Commons · Quick Cleaners (Ste D)2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha · 0.20 mi1,2001,000-1,500 SF inline dry service16.889.1226.00NNN-eq (Signed Gross)n/asignedMTM in Jan 2026 OM
Silvernail Commons · Ali Ali Healing (Ste F)2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha · 0.20 mi900<1,000 SF inline wellness/retail21.889.1231.00NNN-eq (Signed MG)2026-09-30956d ↗04/20/2019 -> 12/01/2021 (Catylist #20970326)
Silvernail Commons · Cher Nails (Ste G)2177 Silvernail Rd, Waukesha · 0.20 mi900<1,000 SF inline personal service27.309.1236.42NNN-eq (Signed Gross)2028-02-29signedSigned thru 02/2028
Comps only (n=7)mean 17.68 · med 15.00
Loading map
Front rent comp pins · subject in yellowMap data © OpenStreetMap contributors · tiles by OpenFreeMap
NNN occupancy cost ·

Your $6.17/SF load is honest, and the tax appeal made it cheaper

Billed 2026$6.17per SF, 4 executed leases
Actual post-appeal$5.53dues + tax + insurance / 27,458 SF
Pre-appeal$6.10same pool, 2024 tax
County median$5.4798 centers, Oct 2025 · CARW Nov 2026: $5.49

Your 2025 net tax is $1.03/SF, rank 1 of 17 tier-1 corridor centers (median $2.06/SF; the 2177 neighbor pays $2.60/SF). The appeal cut the occupancy cost by $0.57/SF.

Corridor published NNN loads (5 centers)
PropertyLoad $/SFNote
Silvernail Commons, 2177 Silvernail Rd (0.21 mi)6.70$6.70/SF realized Year 1 recovery ($9.12/SF budgeted 2026 total OpEx; 2025 county tax bill $26,934.81 = $2.60/SF)
Pewaukee Crossings Condo, N20W22951 Watertown Rd (3.18 mi)7.41$7.41/SF 2026 Tax/CAM in Dec 2025 Suntide sale brochure ($6.38/SF on Aug 2026 Judson lease flyer)
2720 N Grandview Blvd, Waukesha (0.29 mi)7.70Published CAM, insurance, and tax estimate on Founders 3 flyer
Grandview Crossing, 2450 N Grandview Blvd (0.42 mi)7.50Taxes and insurance $2.95/SF + CAM $4.55/SF on Mid-America flyer
Silvernail Plaza East, 2100 Silvernail Rd (0.25 mi)5.22Published NNN expenses on Mid-America Metro Market strip flyer ($4.50/SF FY2025 SEC ABS-EE audited OpEx)
Silvernail Plaza West, 2020-2030 Silvernail Rd (0.37 mi)5.00$5.00/SF 2026 Founders 3 lease flyer estimate ($4.00/SF 2024 actual in Sep 2025 sale OM)
Meadowbrook Marketplace, 821 Meadowbrook Rd (1.87 mi)4.18$4.18/SF Mid-America flyer ($4.23/SF Nov 2026 SEC ABS-EE TTM audited OpEx at 99.82% occupancy)
The whole board
Loading map
All 18 comp pins across the 5 sets · toggle layers · subject in yellowMap data © OpenStreetMap contributors · tiles by OpenFreeMap

Every comp row opens to its source quote, photo, and hosted PDF. The full candidate ledger, including cut comps and reasons, lives in Sources.

The income

From the books to the underwriting.

Three columns: what the last 9 months actually produced, what today’s signed leases produce, and what market rents produce. Every line ties to the Anderson Commercial Group statement.

NOI trailing 9 mo, annualized$279,960one-time items stripped
NOI today’s leases$328,39737.7% expense ratio
NOI at market rents$330,28037.6% expense ratio
NOI per SF today$11.9627,458 SF basis
Line itemTrailing 9 Mo (Annualized) Today's LeasesAt Market Rents
Income
GL 4102-00$355,901$396,663$382,936
GL 4107-00$1,200$1,200$0
GL 4151-00$0$0$0
GL 4308-00$0$0$0
GL 4510-00, 4620-00, 4650-00, 4610-00$114,846$157,061$174,074
GL 4511-00$0$0$0
GL 4630-00, 4631-00$0$0$0
modeled$0$-27,746$-27,851
Operating Expenses
GL 5800-00, 5850-00$116,754$116,754$116,754
GL 5627-00$29,025$28,370$28,370
GL 5620-00$8,863$6,596$6,596
GL 5610-00$24,033$26,249$26,347
GL 5202-00, 6210-00, 6212-00, 6215-00$4,775$4,775$4,775
GL 6110-00, 6115-00, 6121-00, 6122-00, 6156-00$2,118$2,118$2,118
GL 6230-00, 6240-00, 6240-05$1,825$1,825$1,825
GL 6360-00, 6335-00, 6372-00$4,595$4,595$4,595
GL 6220-00, 6280-00, 6340-00$0$0$0
modeled$0$7,500$7,500
$471,947$527,179$529,160
Total Operating Expenses$191,988$198,781$198,880
$279,960$328,397$330,280
40.7%37.7%37.6%

27,458 SF stated once; annual dollars throughout; uniform 5.0% vacancy allowance across both forward columns. Tap any line item for the math and the as-booked GL figure.

Below NOI, never in the cap-rate math

ItemYTD 9 moWhy it sits below the line
Leasing Commission ExpenseGL 6375-00$0.00No leasing commission was booked to expense this year. Commissions on the 2026 leases are carried on the balance sheet as a deferred asset and amortized, not run through the operating statement.
Mortgage InterestGL 6510-00$83,384.94Interest on the WaterStone Bank loan at 6.875% on a $1,582,542.70 balance. Debt service is not an operating expense, so it sits below net operating income and never in the cap-rate math.
Buildouts / Tenant ImprovementsGL 9501-00$14,282.39Capital spending on tenant improvements for the 2026 leases, booked below net operating income. It is not an operating cost and it does not annualize.
Year-end 2027

Two rollovers, +$1,883/yr NOI

Re-leasing expiring Suite 2319 (Marillian's Massage, 672 SF) at $17.00/SF + NNN and converting Mission Breakout from $14.00/SF MG to $9.00/SF + NNN at year-end 2027, while keeping all locked-in leases at contract.

NOI after rollovers$330,280
Value at 9.00% cap$3,669,779
Expense risk shifted to tenants$18,868/yr
Sensitivity, recovery cross-check, and GL audit

Vacancy sensitivity

Both forward columns carry the same , so only rent and recoveries move value. At a harsher 7.0% allowance:

  • Today's leases NOI: $317,851 (vs $332,792 at 5.0%)
  • At market NOI: $359,484 (vs $370,925 at 5.0%)

Recovery cross-check

Recoverable cost pool $178,200 × 83.8% NNN share of SF = $149,274 supported. Contracted recoveries on occupied suites: $149,047. The rent roll reconciles to the penny.

GL audit

37 accounts mapped, 0 duplicates. YTD income $362,004.27, operating expense $156,023.72, below-NOI items $97,667.33. Management fee runs 4.98% of collected income. No CAM cap, expense stop, or gross-up clause is recommended; recoveries remain uniform pro-rata across the rent roll.

At-market suite plan: all 15 suites, line by line
SuiteTenantSFBase $/SFAnnual baseAnnual NNNTreatment
2301 & 2307Plaza Garibaldi (El Nayarita MTZ Restaurant LLC)3,163$20.00$63,260$19,516Locked-in lease kept at contract ($20.00/SF NNN)
2305 & 2303Midwest Dental2,446$18.90$46,229$19,908Locked-in lease kept at contract ($18.90/SF NNN)
2309, 2317 & 2321American Advantage Insurance3,242$11.33$36,732$19,784Locked-in lease kept at contract ($11.33/SF NNN)
2315The Piano Lab LLC1,250$14.50$18,125$7,713Locked-in lease kept at contract ($14.50/SF NNN)
2319Marillian Massage, LLC672$17.00$11,424$4,146Re-lease expiring massage suite (03/31/2027) at $17.00/SF + $6.17/SF NNN
2323Believe Spa and Nails, LLC1,250$14.50$18,125$7,713Locked-in lease kept at contract ($14.50/SF NNN)
2327 & 2325Black Gold Sports Cards, LLC2,974$15.12$44,960$18,158Locked-in lease kept at contract ($15.12/SF NNN)
2329Caught Looking Cards Inc.1,451$9.33$13,538$8,960Locked-in lease kept at contract ($9.33/SF NNN)
2329A + 2329BVacant (combined)1,399$10.00$13,990$8,632Vacant 2329A + 2329B combined (1,399 SF) leased at $10.00/SF + $6.17/SF NNN
2329BJavaTwist (storage)0$0.00$0$0100 SF storage combined back into 2329A when 2329A leases (separate $1,200/yr storage drops to $0)
2331JavaTwist, LLC790$15.91$12,569$6,979Locked-in lease kept at contract ($15.91/SF NNN)
2333Slowinski & Associates, SC971$16.73$16,241$5,043Locked-in lease kept at contract ($16.73/SF NNN)
2335 & 2337Mission Breakout, LLC3,058$9.00$27,522$18,868Re-lease expiring MG ($14.00/SF) at $9.00/SF + $6.17/SF NNN ($15.17/SF all-in)
2343, 2339A & 2339BShepherd Chiropractic Clinic S.C.3,135$13.92$43,651$18,431Locked-in lease kept at contract ($13.92/SF NNN)
2345Essentially For You LLC1,657$10.00$16,570$10,224Locked-in lease kept at contract ($10.00/SF NNN)
The governance

67.3% of the votes. Full control.

You own 61.1% of the square footage, but recorded Exhibit A gives your 21 units 67.3% of the association votes. That clears both supermajority thresholds alone, so no artificial condo discount is deducted from value.

Your 21 units clear the two-thirds solo by +0.63 votes and the Bylaws threshold by +0.30 votes. Recorded Exhibit A fixes 100.0 votes across the complex.

Your units21 of 3121 tax parcels
Share of SF61.1%27,458 of 44,941 SF
Share of assessment56.4%association roll
Haircut applied$0off-market testing prices control directly

The other side of the table

5 third-party owners hold the remaining 32.7 votes across 7 parcels (10 units):

  • 2311 Silvernail Road LLC (2311, 2313)
  • Lennyland Limited LLC (2341)
  • Gypsy Properties LLC (2347 & 2349, bought Jan 2026)
  • 2351 Silvernail

What the regime still requires

  • Dissolving the condominium into a regular single-owner parcel requires 100% consent of all unit owners and lenders (Wis. Stat. 703.28(1)). Owning 21 of 31 units (61.1% of SF) cannot force termination.
  • Major structural changes after casualty require a 75% vote (Wis. Stat. 703.18(2)(b)); 61.1% sits below that mark.
  • Two expense layers: condo dues ($4.25/SF/yr) sit alongside suite upkeep, and the association controls master shell insurance (Wis. Stat. 703.17(1)).
  • 21 separate tax bills and HOA reserve/bylaw review in buyer due diligence (each unit is individually lienable under a standard commercial bank blanket mortgage, just like your WaterStone Bank loan).

Recorded unit trades inside your own complex

UnitDatePrice SF$/SFFinancing
2347 & 234902/13/2024$295,0002,670$110.49Conventional
2347 & 2349 (resale, Doc #4857695)01/15/2026$291,8002,670$109.29Cash2,670 SF complex roll ($116.72/SF on 2,500 SF Catylist record)
235103/22/2024$480,0002,300$208.70Conventional + SBA (owner-user)2,300 SF listing (2,500 SF assessor = $192.00/SF)

Small-bay unit trades clear $109 to $209/SF one suite at a time. Your bulk asking prices sit at $132.93 to $145.68/SF for the whole 27,458 SF, with one closing and one clock.

The empirical condo gap, decomposed

Your 2024 bulk buy at $79.03/SF vs the fee-simple strip across the street at $106.17/SF is a raw -25.6% spread. Separating the 8.5-point income and tenancy difference from the raw -25.6% spread to 2100-2160 Silvernail Rd leaves a -17.1% additive (-18.6% multiplicative) legal-form gap, supporting an 8% to 12% bulk condo discount (10% midpoint).

Textbook remedy: 8% to 12% off Sales and GRM, or +50 to +100 on the cap. On today's direct-cap value that haircut would cost $289,363 (7.8%): $3,730,856 down to $3,441,493.

Why the discount is $0

Apply the condo discount once at buyer pricing: either a 10% haircut on Sales and GRM baselines or +75 bps (+0.75%) on the cap rate, never both on the same approach and never inside NOI.

Lower back-courtyard rents ($10.00 to $13.00/SF NNN across 54% of your SF) are already inside Net Operating Income, so physical suite mix is never penalized twice.

The raw -25.6% $/SF gap between your 2024 purchase ($79.03/SF) and 2100-2160 Silvernail Rd ($106.17/SF) mixes occupancy and rent differences with condo title; only the 10% / +75 bps title portion is applied here. With 67.3% voting control, the governance risk a haircut prices is already yours to direct. Real buyers test that off-market at $3,999,999 instead of a spreadsheet penalty.

The value

Four approaches. Two prices.

Direct capitalization leads; the sales and GRM approaches cross-check it. No artificial condo haircut is applied. The reconciled judgment is a two-price strategy, not a single point estimate.

Aspirational · circulated off-market $3,999,999 $145.68/SF · 8.25% (8.21% today / 8.26% at market)
Bottom price · the floor $3,649,999 $132.93/SF · 9.00% cap (your 9.45% buy cap cut 45 for the doubled )
The NOI underneath $328,397 today's leases · $330,280 at market (+$1,883/yr)

Two clear prices govern the sale. Your bottom price is $3,649,999 ($132.93/SF), anchored at a 9.00% cap on today's $328,397 NOI: your original 9.45% acquisition cap tightened 45 bps to account for the doubled WALT (1.66 yr to 2.91 yr, 0% MTM, 83.8% NNN). Your aspirational price is $3,999,999 ($145.68/SF), anchored at 8.25% cap (8.21% today / 8.26% at market): that price assumes buyers accept the tenant sales reports, we solve the Suite 2329A vacancy fears, and the condo discount is ignored so the center clears right near the 8.31% Waukesha closed strip median cap. Aspirational ($3,999,999) is what gets circulated off-market.

Cap Rate (Direct Capitalization) Primary method

%

$328,397 NOI today / $330,280 at market

Comp band: 7.67 to 8.92 (med 8.30)%
Today's leases$3,649,999
At market rents$3,999,999
Full band, proof, and applied basis
Scenario LowCentralHigh
Today's leases$3,649,999$3,649,999$3,999,999
At market rents$3,669,779$3,999,999$4,003,395
  • At 8.92% (Silvernail Plaza realized cap across the street): $3,730,856 today -> rounded to $3,725,000.
  • At 8.30% (6-sale closed strip median): $4,009,547 today.
  • At 7.67% (25th-percentile tight cap): $4,338,884 today.

Primary valuation method. Buyers underwrite multi-tenant strip income directly off Net Operating Income; zero artificial condo spread is deducted.

Applied: Two-price strategy: $3,649,999 bottom price at 9.00% cap (your original 9.45% acquisition cap cut 45 bps for the doubled WALT), and $3,999,999 aspirational price at 8.25% cap (8.21% today / 8.26% at-market, assuming buyers accept tenant sales reports, vacancy fears are solved, and the condo discount is ignored so we clear right near the 8.31% market median cap).

No condo penalty applied (67.3% supermajority voting control)

Sales Comparison: Price per SF

$/SF

27,458 SF owned

Comp band: $109.33 to $151.18 (med $120.97)/SF
Today's leases$3,321,594
At market rents$3,321,594
Full band, proof, and applied basis
Scenario LowCentralHigh
Today's leases$3,001,983$3,321,594$4,151,100
At market rents$3,001,983$3,321,594$4,151,100
  • 7-sale $/SF band: $109.33 / $120.97 / $151.18 per SF.
  • Your reconciled $3,725,000 value equals $135.66/SF, right inside the closed strip interquartile band.

7 closed Waukesha County retail strip/center deeds. Median $120.97/SF; upper quartile $151.18/SF.

Unadjusted across 7 closed retail deeds (2024-2026)

Sales Comparison: Price per Suite

$/suite

15 commercial suites (small-bay strip basis)

Comp band: $285,070 to $454,762 (med $340,972)/suite
Today's leases$5,114,580
At market rents$5,114,580
Full band, proof, and applied basis
Scenario LowCentralHigh
Today's leases$4,276,042$5,114,580$6,821,422
At market rents$4,276,042$5,114,580$6,821,422
  • Small-bay strip $/Suite median: $340,972/suite (all-7 median incl. multi-box centers: $635,714/suite).
  • Your $3,725,000 value equals $248,333/suite across 15 suites.

7 closed Waukesha County retail strip/center deeds. Median $120.97/SF; upper quartile $151.18/SF.

4 closed small-bay strips (4-9 suites; anchor boxes excluded)

Gross Rent Multiple

x EGI

$533,920 raw contracted gross today / $557,011 at market (no vacancy deduction)

Comp band: 8.25x to 9.24x (med 8.81x)
Today's leases$4,703,835
At market rents$4,907,267
Full band, proof, and applied basis
Scenario LowCentralHigh
Today's leases$4,404,840$4,703,835$4,933,421
At market rents$4,595,341$4,907,267$5,146,782
  • At Silvernail Plaza's 7.49x closed GRM: $0 today on raw contracted gross rent ($0).
  • GRM ignores expense load differences across centers; Direct Cap leads valuation.

Same-corridor check: Silvernail Plaza (2100-2160 Silvernail Rd) closed at 7.49x. On your raw contracted gross that gives $3,999,061 today and $4,172,012 at market. Your own asking prices sit at 6.84x (bottom) to 7.49x (aspirational), below the 8.25x to 9.24x comp band: buyers get more rent per dollar here than at any closed comp.

Cross-check on Effective Gross Income. Silvernail Plaza across the street closed at 7.49x EGI ($3,983,000 on your $531,804 EGI).

Unadjusted (check Silvernail Plaza's 7.49x same-corridor close)

Omitted: replacement cost does not set buyer pricing on a 1991 multi-owner commercial condominium. 27,458 SF (15 suites across 21 condo units); bands are identical across both rent scenarios except where NOI itself moves. Reconciled on in-place NOI and corridor comps with zero artificial condo discount. Rounding: nearest $25,000.

Where the market clears

Off-market circulation$3,999,9998.25% cap, aspirational
Bottom price$3,649,9999.00% cap floor

Circulate off-market at $3,999,999 (8.25% cap: assumes buyers accept our tenant sales reports, we solve vacancy fears, and the condo discount is ignored so we clear right near the 8.31% market median cap) against a $3,649,999 bottom price (your original 9.45% acquisition cap cut to 9.00% for the doubled WALT).

The $350,000 spread, explained

Because most leases are locked in through 2029-2031, at-market upside focuses strictly on the two 2027 rollovers: re-leasing expiring Suite 2319 (Marillian's Massage) at $17.00/SF + NNN and converting Mission Breakout from $14.00/SF Modified Gross to $9.00/SF + NNN, lifting NOI by +$1,883/yr (from $328,397 to $330,280) and shifting $18,868/yr of expense risk off your books. The $350,000 spread between your $3,649,999 bottom price (9.00% cap) and $3,999,999 aspirational price (8.25% cap) is cap-rate compression earned by proving tenant health, solving vacancy, and ignoring the condo discount.

  • Rent and recovery changes: +$3,285.98/yr
  • Vacancy allowance change: $-104.30/yr
  • Management fee change: $-98.67/yr
The game plan

Four moves before you list.

Each move is cheap, reversible, and aimed at the same target: prove tenant health, kill the vacancy fear, and let the off-market price do the work before a public portal ever sees the center.

01
Cap-rate compression

Collect tenant gross-sales reports now to prove store health and compress the cap rate

+$105K to $115Kvalue gained per 25 bps of cap-rate compression

All 3 leases signed since April 2026 (The Piano Lab, Believe Spa & Nails, and Plaza Garibaldi, 5,663 SF) already require certified annual gross sales and monthly revenue breakdowns under Section 36. Start collecting those reports on schedule, request voluntary sales figures from anchor retail/service tenants (Black Gold Sports Cards, JavaTwist, Midwest Dental, Mission Breakout), and add Section 36 to every upcoming renewal. Documented rent-to-sales ratios below 8% to 10% prove your tenants are thriving and give buyers confidence to bid closer to an 8.00% to 8.30% cap rate.

02
100% occupancy + positive ROI

Tap WaterStone Bank for a $100K interest-only TI line to build the restroom and lease Suite 2329A at 100% occupancy

$604/mo IOcarry on $100K @ 7.25% (46.1% LTV) · creates +$214K to $233K in sale value

You do not need $100,000 cash out of pocket to finish vacant Suite 2329A (1,299 SF). Ask WaterStone Bank for a $100,000 co-terminous TI line maturing 12/01/2027 at 7.25% APR: combined debt rises to $1,682,543, which is only 46.1% LTV on your $3,649,999 floor (42.1% LTV on $3,999,999). Interest-only carry is just $604/mo ($3,625 over 6 months; or $723 to $746/mo P&I if amortized on your 25-year schedule). Leasing 2329A at $10.00/SF + $6.17/SF NNN adds $21,005/yr of gross rent (+$19,246/yr stabilized NOI), adds $213,800 to $233,300 in value at an 8.25% to 9.00% cap, drops $3,999,999 raw gross GRM from 7.49x to 7.21x, kills buyer fear over corridor days on market and plumbing permits, and lets Rova market the center at a rare 100% occupancy for this corridor (avoiding the 2-year Seller Master Lease Pewaukee Crossings had to pledge on Suite 105).

$604/mo interest-only carry $3,625 total over 6 months $723 to $746/mo if P&I, 25-yr schedule 46.1% / 42.1% combined LTV, floor / aspirational +$21,005/yr gross rent from 2329A +$213,800 to $233,300 sale value at 9.00% to 8.25% cap 7.49x to 7.21x raw GRM at $3,999,999
03
Zero days-on-market risk

Circulate $3,999,999 off-market first before touching public portals

$3,999,999aspirational (8.25% cap) vs. $3,649,999 floor (9.00% cap)

Circulate off-market at $3,999,999 (8.25% cap: 8.21% today / 8.26% at market) rather than going straight to MLS. That aspirational price assumes buyers accept tenant sales reports, we solve the Suite 2329A vacancy fears, and the condo discount is ignored so we clear right near the 8.31% market median cap. Your $3,649,999 bottom price (9.00% cap, down from your 9.45% buy cap for the doubled WALT) protects the floor without racking up public days on market or price-cut history.

04
Next-door development audit

Pitch the approved 5-story mixed-use build next door (2417 Silvernail) & nearby senior living now, don't wait past your Dec 2027 balloon

76 + 119 unitsapproved next door at 2417 Silvernail + under construction 1.4 mi SW

Local chatter about 'senior housing next door' blended two separate City-approved projects: (1) Directly next door west at 2417 Silvernail Rd, the Plan Commission unanimously approved 'Silvernail Springs' (Dec 17, 2025), a 5-story, 76-unit apartment building with 2,700-3,000 SF of ground-floor commercial. Because demolition had not started as of late 2026, it will not finish by Spring 2027, and waiting for completion would collide with your December 2027 WaterStone balloon. (2) Meanwhile, 1.4 mi SW, 119-unit Lilyrose Senior Living is under construction for Summer 2027. Sell the approved 5-story renderings now: 76 walkable apartments next door kills the 'end of the retail road' narrative immediately.

The demand story next door

Next Door West · 2417 Silvernail Rd ('Silvernail Springs') rendering

Next Door West · 2417 Silvernail Rd ('Silvernail Springs')

5 stories · 76 market-rate apartments + 2,700 to 3,000 SF ground-floor commercial · Approved 4 to 0 Dec 17, 2025

Approved (PC25-0195 & PC25-0175); not yet broken ground in late 2026, will not finish by Spring 2027

Replaces the low-profile office building immediately west of Silvernail Village (east of the existing 90-unit 62+ Silvernail Senior Apartments at 2451 Silvernail Rd). Adds 76 walkable households right at your western driveway.

1.4 Miles SW · Lilyrose Senior Living (1701 Coren Hills Dr / Meadowbrook Rd) rendering

1.4 Miles SW · Lilyrose Senior Living (1701 Coren Hills Dr / Meadowbrook Rd)

119 senior living units (64 IL/AL + 25 Enhanced AL + 30 Memory Care) · 165,000 SF · Tukka Properties / Iconica / Lifespark

Under construction (broke ground Spring 2026) · Scheduled to open Summer 2027

Approved by Waukesha Common Council Nov 2025 / Feb 2026 and actively under construction in 2026 for a Summer 2027 opening, expanding affluent senior, family-visitor, and healthcare demand across the immediate west Waukesha / Silvernail trade area.

Timing

2417 Silvernail Rd has not broken ground yet and will not finish by Spring 2027; waiting for vertical completion pushes into your December 2027 WaterStone maturity. Package the City-approved 5-story renderings with the $3,999,999 off-market circulation now so buyers underwrite 76 new walkable households next door while you control your 1031 clock.

The proceeds

What you would walk away with.

Move the price, the commission, or the credits and the waterfall updates live. Defaults match the two-price strategy: the bottom price carries a $100,000 buyer TI credit for the unfinished Suite 2329A restroom; the aspirational price assumes 2329A is built out and leased.

slide or type
$
Implied cap on today's $328,397 NOI: 9.00%
%
of the sale price
$
syncs with the % field
$
Waukesha County flat fee
$
, GAP, settlement
$
Bottom ($3,649,999) defaults to a $100,000 buyer TI credit for the unfinished Suite 2329A restroom; Aspirational ($3,999,999) defaults to $0 assuming 2329A is built out and leased.
Pay off the WaterStone loan at closing
$1,582,542.70 principal, 6.875% fixed, matures 12/01/2027 (loan 32008685-7747). Balance per the 09/30/2026 balance sheet.
(0.3%, paid by seller)
Wis. Stat. 77.22: 30 cents per $100 of value. Statute ↗
$10,950
You would walk away with
$1,734,976
before income or capital-gains taxes
Sale price$3,649,999
Brokerage commission−$218,999.94
WI transfer fee−$10,950
Deed recording−$30
Title & closing−$2,500
Buyer TI / repair credit−$100,000
Total selling costs−$332,479.94
WaterStone payoff−$1,582,542.70
Net before taxes$1,734,976.36
Price gain over your $2,170,000 basis$1,479,999

Before income or capital-gains taxes; review 1031 deferral with your CPA. A can defer the gain; one bulk closing keeps a single 45-day identification and 180-day exchange window.

Bottom · 9.00% cap$3,649,999$1,734,976with $100,000 TI credit
Aspirational · 8.25% cap$3,999,999$2,162,9262329A built out, $0 credit
What you paid · Nov 2024$2,170,000$448,217same costs, same payoff
The tax appeal

The 2025 roll already moved.

Waukesha County cut the 21-unit assessment to your purchase price. Land stayed put; the entire reduction came out of improvements. The saving is recurring, and it flows straight into NOI.

−36.3%net general taxes, 2024 to 2025
Annual saving$16,075.79recurring, in NOI
Tax load today$1.03/SFvs $1.62/SF on the 2024 roll
Year-1 net saving$7,150.79after the appeal fee

2024 roll · prior owner

  • Assessed: $2,930,500 (land $1,430,500 + improvements $1,500,000)
  • Assessment ratio: 92.07%
  • Net general tax: $44,255.87
  • Special assessments: $190.00
  • Total bill: $44,445.87

2025 roll · Silvernail Village LLC

  • Assessed: $2,170,000 (land $1,430,500 + improvements $739,500)
  • Assessment ratio: 97.43% of $2,227,241 estimated fair market
  • Net general tax: $28,180.08
  • Special assessments: $190.00 (5 fire-inspection lines at $38)
  • Total bill: $28,370.08

Waukesha County's 2025 roll lowered the total assessment across your 21 units from $3,399,300 to $2,170,000, matching your $2,170,000 purchase price, with the entire cut taken on improvements while land stayed at $1,430,500. The 09/30/2026 management report notes a $7,150.79 net Year 1 tax-appeal saving after the appeal fee, against the $16,075.79 gross annual tax drop.

Verify any unit yourself

Waukesha County tax portal ↗ · Open https://tax.waukeshacounty.gov -> Search Parcel ID -> enter the Tax Key (for example WAKC0974017) -> Tax Listing / Tax Bill -> select the Tax Year

All 21 units: tax keys, assessments, and bills (sortable)
Tax key
2301WAKC0974017$238,900$176,900$-62,000$3,642.31$2,329.23$1,313.08
2303WAKC0974018$99,800$73,900$-25,900$1,493.36$946.89$546.47
2305WAKC0974019$145,600$107,800$-37,800$2,200.92$1,401.86$799.06
2307WAKC0974020$99,800$73,900$-25,900$1,493.36$946.89$546.47
2309WAKC0974021$99,800$73,900$-25,900$1,493.36$946.89$546.47
2315WAKC0974024$131,500$97,400$-34,100$1,983.10$1,262.27$720.83
2317WAKC0974025$112,700$83,500$-29,200$1,692.65$1,075.74$616.91
2319WAKC0974026$151,400$112,100$-39,300$2,290.52$1,459.56$830.96
2321WAKC0974027$145,600$107,800$-37,800$2,200.92$1,401.86$799.06
2323WAKC0974028$151,400$112,100$-39,300$2,290.52$1,459.56$830.96
2325WAKC0974029$145,600$107,800$-37,800$2,200.92$1,401.86$799.06
2327WAKC0974030$260,900$193,200$-67,700$3,982.18$2,547.98$1,434.20
2329WAKC0974031$158,400$117,300$-41,100$2,398.67$1,529.35$869.32
2331WAKC0974032$97,100$71,900$-25,200$1,451.66$920.06$531.60
2333WAKC0974033$97,100$71,900$-25,200$1,451.66$920.06$531.60
2335WAKC0974034$136,800$101,300$-35,500$2,064.98$1,314.61$750.37
2337WAKC0974035$136,800$101,300$-35,500$2,064.98$1,314.61$750.37
2343WAKC0974038$171,000$126,600$-44,400$2,593.34$1,654.16$939.18
2345WAKC0974039$160,000$118,500$-41,500$2,423.40$1,545.46$877.94
2339AWAKC0974036$132,100$97,800$-34,300$1,992.37$1,267.64$724.73
2339BWAKC0974036001$58,200$43,100$-15,100$850.69$533.54$317.15
All 21 units$2,930,500$2,170,000$-760,500$44,255.87$28,180.08$16,075.79

Portal deep-link URLs that carry a parcel key in the query string redirect to the portal home without a session cookie minted by the on-site search, so they are never published. The portal root, the exact Tax Key and the click path are published instead, and every unit record repeats them.

The decision

Three questions. One study.

What is it worth? $3,649,999 floor, $3,999,999 circulated off-market. How does it go to market? Tenant sales reports first, the WaterStone TI line second, off-market circulation third, and the approved next-door renderings in every package. Who earns the listing? The firm that shows its math, links every figure to its source, and tells you what it cannot prove.

Every number here traces to a recorded document, a signed lease, a management statement, or a closed deed. The clock, the December 2027 balloon, and the tax appeal are all dated, so the decision can be made on a calendar, not a feeling.

Mark Kvetkovskiy, CCIM
mark.k@rova.re
Rova Real Estate
Full source ledger Silvernail Village LLC · November 2026